Skip to main content ↑ ↓

Notice

Please note that most of the software linked on this forum is likely to be safe to use. If you are unsure, feel free to ask in the relevant topics, or send a private message to an administrator or moderator. To help curb the problems of false positives, or in the event that you do find actual malware, you can contribute through the article linked here.
Topic: any improvements in getting AAC into .avi/.ogm ? (Read 4493 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

any improvements in getting AAC into .avi/.ogm ?

does anybody know if  there is any improvements in getting AAC sound into .avi or .ogm

the last time i tried with Nic's AAC Dshow filter it was WAY out of sync in .avi
and oggmux could not mux the AAC sound correctly into .ogm container
Sven Bent - Denmark

any improvements in getting AAC into .avi/.ogm ?

Reply #1 –
AAC will never go into AVI (due to its VBR nature)...but It could go into Ogg. But because the filters aren't opensource I dont use OGM/Ogg so I won't re-write the filter...

Perhaps MCF, NSIS' or MP4 will be the answer for movies with AAC when they become popular (well, obviously the last one...  )

Cheers,
-Nic

any improvements in getting AAC into .avi/.ogm ?

Reply #2 –
Have you tried to use GraphEdit and mux it manually? With adding a wav header before muxing, it should work then, but I wouldn´t do that, because the file even when it is play/seekable maybe not compatible with future AAC Decoders.

any improvements in getting AAC into .avi/.ogm ?

Reply #3 –
Quote
Originally posted by Nic
AAC will never go into AVI (due to its VBR nature)...but It could go into Ogg. But because the filters aren't opensource I dont use OGM/Ogg so I won't re-write the filter...

Perhaps MCF, NSIS' or MP4 will be the answer for movies with AAC when they become popular (well, obviously the last one...  )

Cheers,
-Nic


When we can make MPEG4 compatible "Backups", it will be a big day to aac, but heck, the problem isnt aac, is the video codec that ain't supported by MPEG4IP tools, but i heard its in the works

any improvements in getting AAC into .avi/.ogm ?

Reply #4 –
mpeg4 just doesn't have all the other godies like txt subtitles and chapters support
Sven Bent - Denmark

any improvements in getting AAC into .avi/.ogm ?

Reply #5 –
Tell me more about mpeg4IP, I know nothing about it, but am interested
"You can fight without ever winning, but never win without a fight."  Neil Peart  'Resist'

any improvements in getting AAC into .avi/.ogm ?

Reply #6 –
You can try:
mpeg4ip.sf.net



I heard recently that later xvid versions arent compatible, but have yet to find exactly why....ill work on it

-Nic

any improvements in getting AAC into .avi/.ogm ?

Reply #7 –
You can find builds of MPEG4IP at RareWares: http://www.inf.ufpr.br/~rja00/
There is also an MPEG4IP-based windows-tool "mp4UI" that is easier to use (no CLI), you can download it at: http://www.mediacruiser.de/mp4UI/
Quote
I heard recently that later xvid versions arent compatible, but have yet to find exactly why....ill work on it

Really? Also when you deactivate b-frames and use "DIVX" as FourCC?
 

any improvements in getting AAC into .avi/.ogm ?

Reply #8 –
I think MPEG4IP is using the xvid decoder currently.
At least there's a plugin directory called xvid in CVS. The xvid lib in the mpeg4ip CVS dates 8.3.2002. Maybe they just added that recently, I'm not sure.

Menno

any improvements in getting AAC into .avi/.ogm ?

Reply #9 –
in the mean time, it would be cool to be able to mux aac to ogm for that subtitle and chapter support, but hell, ogg ds filter has been static for a while, and since nic wont rewrite his filter to comply with ogm, we are doomed to for mp4 (maybe a year  )

any improvements in getting AAC into .avi/.ogm ?

Reply #10 –
Quote
ogg ds filter has been static for a while

I mailed with Tobias a few days ago, he will release the next version soon, he wants to implement Theora (just passing the data to the On2-Truemotion-Filter) and support for ShoutCast/IceCast. And some minor bugfix.